Site Logo - PoolForce

A Saltwater Pool or Chlorine Pool; Which One’s for You

PoolForce - Detached spa with spillovers Page - Detached spa with spillovers - Saltwater Pool or Chlorine Pool

Choosing the right type of pool for your home is no small decision. You’ve probably heard a lot about what a saltwater pool is, but how do they stack up against traditional chlorine pools? In this in-depth article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of saltwater and chlorine pools to help you make an educated decision.

Saltwater Pools

Saltwater pools use an electrolytic chlorine generator that chemically breaks down salt to produce chlorine. Contrary to popular belief, saltwater pools are not devoid of chlorine. Rather, they generate their own chlorine, eliminating the need for manual chlorine addition.

Pro: Gentler on Eyes and Skin

Saltwater pools are generally softer on your skin and eyes. This is because the electrolytic chlorine generator reduces the occurrence of chloramines, which are responsible for the notorious “pool smell” and can cause skin irritation and red eyes.

Con: Higher Initial Costs

Saltwater pools require a considerable upfront investment. The electrolytic chlorine generator can cost up to $2,500, and that’s not including the pool’s basic setup, which ranges between $10,000 to $40,000. In contrast, a chlorine system might only set you back $100 to $400.

The Lowdown on Chlorine Pools

Traditional chlorine pools use store-bought chlorine or bromine to disinfect the water. They are a tried-and-true method but come with their own sets of pros and cons.

Pro: Lower Installation Costs

The upfront cost of installing a chlorine pool is generally lower than that of a saltwater pool. With fewer specialized components to purchase, you can save substantially on initial expenses.

Con: Ongoing Maintenance

Chlorine pools require frequent manual testing and addition of chemicals to balance pH, calcium hardness, and total alkalinity. This can add up both in terms of time and money over the long run.

Side-by-Side Maintenance Comparison

A Saltwater Pool or Chlorine Pool; Which One's for You

Saltwater Pools: Less Chemical Management

Saltwater pools usually require less day-to-day chemical management. Just add salt at the beginning of the swimming season, and the electrolytic chlorine generator will do the rest, requiring only bi-weekly tests to ensure chlorine levels remain optimal.

Chlorine Pools: DIY-Friendly Repairs

With a chlorine pool, most issues with water composition can be managed by the owner. Whether it’s adjusting the pH or shocking the pool, you can often handle it yourself without calling in an expert.

How Do They Affect Your Home and Surroundings?

Saltwater Pools: No Chemical Storage

One of the under-discussed benefits of a saltwater pool is that you won’t have to store dangerous chlorine chemicals around your property, offering a more eco-friendly and safer option.

Chlorine Pools: Easier on Equipment and Outdoor Structures

While salt can be corrosive to certain metals and materials, chlorine pools pose less risk to external structures like decks, sheds, and pool equipment.

The Feel Factor: Water Quality and Comfort

Saltwater Pools: Softer Water

Many find the water in saltwater pools to feel softer and more luxurious, thanks to the lower levels of total dissolved solids and chloramines.

Chlorine Pools: Customizability

Chlorine pools give you greater control over the water’s chemical composition. If you like tweaking things to perfection, you might find more satisfaction in maintaining a chlorine pool.

What’s Best for You?

Choosing between a saltwater and chlorine pool ultimately boils down to your priorities. Do you prefer lower upfront costs or less maintenance down the line? Is skin comfort more important, or are you concerned about the long-term impact on your home and surroundings? Consider these factors carefully as you make your decision, or reach out to us, we will be more than glad to help you out.

We hope this comprehensive guide has illuminated the key considerations for choosing between a saltwater and chlorine pool. Happy swimming!


We are with you every splash of the way

Need a pool fix or looking for an upgrade? We’re just one click away to help with all your pool needs.